The Great Holiday Cookie Debate: Which Cookie Reigns Supreme in Vancouver, WA?

It's mid-December in Vancouver, Washington. The house smells like butter, cinnamon, and vanilla. There's flour on every surface. Someone's arguing about whether frosting should be homemade or store-bought. The kids are sneaking cookie dough when they think no one's looking. And somewhere, someone's defending their controversial opinion that chocolate chip cookies are absolutely a Christmas cookie.

Welcome to the Great Holiday Cookie Debate.

After 9+ years of Thanksgiving dinners, holiday parties, and cookie exchanges with clients, friends, and neighbors across Clark County, I've witnessed this debate play out countless times. Sugar cookies vs. gingerbread. Frosted vs. sprinkled. Homemade vs. Crumbl. The passion people have for their holiday cookie preferences rivals their opinions on Daylight Savings Time (which, if you've read my guide to surviving the Big Dark, you know is a topic Clark County residents take seriously).

So let's settle this once and for all—or at least have fun trying. Here's everything you need to know about holiday cookie traditions in Vancouver, WA, from the classics to the controversial, plus where to find the best cookies if baking isn't your thing.

The Holiday Cookie Lineup: Let the Debate Begin

Sugar Cookies: The Frosted Champion

The Case For:

• The ultimate blank canvas for creativity
• Perfect for decorating with kids (memories > perfection)
• Can be cut into festive shapes (trees, snowmen, reindeer)
• Tastes like nostalgia and childhood
• The frosting-to-cookie ratio is chef's kiss

The Case Against:

• Can be bland without good frosting
• The decorating process creates epic kitchen messes
• Someone always makes them rock-hard
• Storing them without the frosting sticking together is impossible

The Verdict: Sugar cookies are the undisputed champion of kid-friendly holiday baking. If you have children, nieces, nephews, or grandkids in Vancouver, sugar cookies aren't optional—they're tradition. The flour-covered counters and misshapen reindeer are part of the magic.

Local Twist: Use Pacific Northwest ingredients like Oregon hazelnuts crushed into the frosting, or a hint of lavender from those summer Gorge hikes dried and added to the dough.

Gingerbread: The Spiced Contender

The Case For:

• Smells like Christmas in cookie form
• Holds up better for shipping/gifting
• That perfect crispy-yet-chewy texture
• Molasses depth of flavor (not just sweet)
• Doubles as both cookie and construction material (houses!)

The Case Against:

• You either love ginger or you don't (no middle ground)
• Can be dry if overbaked
• The strong flavor overpowers everything else on the cookie plate
• Kids often prefer sweeter options

The Verdict: Gingerbread is the adult holiday cookie. It's sophisticated, it's warming, and it pairs perfectly with coffee during those gray Vancouver mornings when the sun doesn't rise until 7:30 AM. If you're hosting a grown-up holiday party, gingerbread cookies (and maybe some gingerbread-flavored cocktails) are the move.

Vancouver Tradition: Make gingerbread men to hang on your tree, or build a gingerbread replica of Fort Vancouver for maximum local pride.

Chocolate Chip: The Controversial Wildcard

The Case For:

• Universally loved by everyone (even cookie haters)
• Not "too Christmassy" for year-round cookie lovers
• Warm, gooey, fresh from the oven = perfection
• No decorating required
• Can be elevated with sea salt, brown butter, different chocolates

The Case Against:

• "It's not even a Christmas cookie!" —traditionalists everywhere
• Doesn't photograph as festively
• Won't win any cookie exchange contests
• Feels lazy compared to decorated sugar cookies

The Verdict: Here's my hot take: chocolate chip cookies absolutely belong on holiday cookie platters. Not every cookie needs to be shaped like a snowflake. Sometimes you just want a warm, melty, chocolate chip cookie while watching Home Alone in your pajamas on a rainy Vancouver evening. That's the holiday spirit.

Crumbl Factor: Speaking of chocolate chip cookies, Crumbl's award-winning Milk Chocolate Chip is their permanent menu item for good reason. Sometimes you don't want to bake—you just want a massive, perfect cookie. No judgment here.

The Dark Horse Contenders

Snickerdoodles: The cinnamon-sugar sleeper hit. Not technically a "Christmas cookie," but the warm spice screams cozy winter vibes. Perfect with hot cocoa after sledding at Battle Ground's snowfall.

Peanut Butter Blossoms: Those cookies with the Hershey's Kiss pressed in the center. A Midwest transplant staple that's made its way to Pacific Northwest cookie plates. The chocolate-peanut butter combo is undefeated.

Russian Tea Cakes (Snowball Cookies): Buttery, nutty, rolled in powdered sugar. They look like little snowballs, melt in your mouth, and are dangerously easy to eat a dozen of.

Shortbread: Simple, buttery, elegant. The minimalist's holiday cookie. Pairs perfectly with tea during those long December nights in Clark County.

Spritz Cookies: Those pressed cookies from a cookie gun. Your grandma probably made them. They're delicate, they come in fun shapes, and they're way harder to make than they look.

Beyond Cookies: Fudge, Peanut Brittle & Holiday Treats

Let's be honest—cookie platters aren't just cookies. The best holiday treat assortments include variety, and that's where fudge and candy come in.

Fudge: The Make-Ahead Hero

Fudge is the unsung hero of holiday gifting. It:

• Lasts longer than cookies (less worry about staleness)
• Can be made days in advance
• Looks impressive but is surprisingly easy
• Cuts into perfect gift-sized squares
• Travels well without breaking

Classic flavors: Chocolate, peanut butter, maple, peppermint
Pacific Northwest twist: Add Oregon hazelnuts, espresso (hello, coffee culture), or sea salt from the Oregon Coast

Pro tip: Line your pan with parchment paper for easy removal and clean cutting. Trust me on this.

Peanut Brittle: The Crunchy Showstopper

Peanut brittle is impressive because it requires precision—you're working with molten sugar at 300°F. But when you nail it? Chef's kiss.

It's sweet, crunchy, nutty, and feels special because most people don't make it anymore. Include it in your cookie tins, and people will remember you.

Vancouver variation: Swap peanuts for Oregon hazelnuts or add a touch of smoked sea salt for that Pacific Northwest sophistication.

The Tradition of Holiday Cookie Making in Vancouver, WA

Here's what I've learned after 14 Clark County Christmases: holiday cookie baking isn't really about the cookies. It's about the tradition.

Why We Keep Baking Every Year

It slows us down. In a season that's rushed and commercialized, spending an afternoon measuring flour and decorating cookies forces you to be present.

It connects generations. Grandma's sugar cookie recipe. Your mom's technique for rolling dough. Teaching your kids how to cream butter and sugar. These are the memories that last.

It creates community. Cookie exchanges with neighbors. Plates delivered to teachers, mail carriers, coworkers. In Vancouver, where community still matters, cookies are currency.

It smells like home. There's something about the scent of vanilla and cinnamon that makes a rainy December day in Southwest Washington feel cozy instead of dreary.

Our Family's Cookie Tradition

Every year, usually the second or third weekend of December, we dedicate a Saturday to cookie chaos. Here's our system:

Morning: Make dough for 3-4 varieties (some chill, some bake immediately)
Afternoon: Baking marathon—ovens running non-stop
Evening: Decorating, packaging, cleanup (okay, mostly cleanup)
Late night: Sampling one of each while watching a holiday movie

We make too many cookies. We always do. But that's the point—there's enough to share, to gift, to freeze for later, and to eat way too many of on the baking day itself.

My personal rule: If you didn't eat raw cookie dough and sneak at least three cookies during the process, you didn't do it right.

When You Don't Want to Bake: Vancouver's Cookie Scene

Let's be real—not everyone has time to bake from scratch. Between work, kids' activities, holiday shopping, and trying to squeeze in a Columbia River Gorge hike before it gets too icy, sometimes you just need to buy the cookies.

No shame. I've done it. And honestly? Vancouver has some excellent options.

Crumbl Cookies: The Vancouver Phenomenon

If you haven't experienced Crumbl yet, here's what you need to know:

Three Vancouver-area locations:

• 616 NE 81st St E, Vancouver (Central Vancouver)
• 8101 NE Parkway Dr, Orchards (East Vancouver)
• 530 SE 192nd Ave, Camas (Clark County)

What makes Crumbl special:

• Rotating weekly menu - New flavors revealed every Sunday night
• Massive cookies - These aren't your standard cookies; they're shareable (in theory)
• Open kitchen - Watch them bake fresh daily
• The pink box - Instantly recognizable, perfect for gifting
• Award-winning Milk Chocolate Chip - Their permanent menu item, and it's that good

Holiday-specific flavors to watch for:

• Sugar Cookie (but make it gourmet with almond icing)
• Gingerbread variants
• Peppermint Bark
• Hot Cocoa Cookie
• Snickerdoodle Cupcake
• Holiday-themed specials (they get creative)

When to go: The app updates at 6 PM Pacific on Sundays with the new week's flavors. Plan accordingly—popular flavors sell out.

Real talk: Are Crumbl cookies "better" than homemade? That's the wrong question. They're different. They're a treat, an experience, a solution when you're short on time. And in a season that's supposed to be joyful, anything that reduces stress and tastes good is a win.

Other Vancouver Cookie Spots

Local Bakeries:

• Cottage Bakery (Long Beach Peninsula)
• Chandelier Bakery
• Simply Sweets
• Larson's Bakery
• Honeycomb Bakery

Coffee Shop Cookies:

• Relevant Coffee (Downtown Vancouver) - Rotating cookies, local and delicious
• Brewed Cafe & Pub - Pairs cookies with coffee perfectly
• Dutch Bros - Okay, not traditional cookies, but those holiday drinks hit different

Cookie Exchange 101: Vancouver Edition

Cookie exchanges are huge in Vancouver, WA. Here's how to nail it:

The Rules

1. Bring enough for everyone - If 10 people attend, bring 10 dozen cookies (or whatever the host specifies)
2. Include recipe cards - People want to recreate your magic
3. Package for transport - No one wants crushed cookies
4. Avoid common allergens when possible - Or label clearly
5. Make something you're proud of - This isn't the time to experiment

What Travels Well

✅ Great for exchanges: Shortbread, biscotti, gingerbread, sturdy sugar cookies, snickerdoodles
❌ Skip these: Delicate frosted cookies, anything with fresh fruit, cookies that require refrigeration

Vancouver-Specific Tips

• Weather matters: It's rainy in December. Plan your packaging accordingly.
• Start early: Don't wait until the week before Christmas—everyone's busy
• Theme it: Pacific Northwest ingredients, locally-sourced, etc.
• Include non-cookie items: Fudge, brittle, and candy add variety

The Giving Tradition: Cookie Plates as Community

In Vancouver and throughout Clark County, there's a beautiful tradition of cookie gifting that I've come to love:

Who gets cookie plates:

• Mail carriers, delivery drivers, garbage collectors
• Teachers, daycare providers, coaches
• Neighbors (especially elderly neighbors who might be alone)
• Coworkers, clients, friends
• First responders (fire stations LOVE cookies)

Why it matters: These small gestures build community. In a world that feels increasingly disconnected, handing someone a plate of homemade cookies and saying "thank you" or "thinking of you" is radical kindness.

I've delivered cookie plates to Vancouver Fire Station 1, to the mail carrier who brings packages to our door year-round, to the barista at Dutch Bros who knows my order, to new neighbors moving into Clark County from out of state.

The cookies themselves don't have to be perfect. It's the thought—the acknowledgment—that someone matters to you.

My Personal Cookie Rankings (Fight Me)

After years of baking, tasting, and debating, here's my definitive Vancouver, WA holiday cookie power ranking:

1. Chocolate Chip (Brown Butter Version) Yes, I'm dying on this hill. Warm, gooey, perfect every time.

2. Gingerbread But only the chewy kind, not the hard kind.

3. Snickerdoodles Underrated. Cinnamon-sugar perfection.

4. Russian Tea Cakes Buttery, melty, gone in two bites.

5. Sugar Cookies (Well-Frosted) The frosting makes or breaks them.

6. Peanut Butter Blossoms Nostalgia points carry these.

7. Shortbread Simple, elegant, but not exciting.

8. Spritz Cookies Pretty, but forgettable flavor-wise.

Your ranking is probably completely different. That's the beauty of the Great Cookie Debate—everyone's passionate, and everyone's right (except people who think raisins belong in cookies—sorry, but no).

The Recipe You Actually Need: Foolproof Sugar Cookies

Since you made it this far, here's the sugar cookie recipe I've used for 12+ years. It's reliable, tastes great, and holds its shape for decorating.

Ingredients:

• 3 cups all-purpose flour
• 2 tsp baking powder
• 1/2 tsp salt
• 1 cup unsalted butter, softened
• 1 1/2 cups granulated sugar
• 2 large eggs
• 2 tsp vanilla extract
• 1/2 tsp almond extract (secret ingredient!)

Instructions:

1. Cream butter and sugar until fluffy (3-4 minutes)
2. Beat in eggs, vanilla, and almond extract
3. Mix flour, baking powder, salt separately
4. Gradually add dry to wet, mix until just combined
5. Divide dough in half, wrap, chill 1+ hours
6. Roll to 1/4 inch thickness on floured surface
7. Cut shapes, place on parchment-lined sheets
8. Bake at 350°F for 8-10 minutes (edges barely golden)
9. Cool completely before frosting

Frosting: Use cream cheese frosting or royal icing depending on your patience level.

Final Thoughts: It's Not Really About the Cookies

Here's what I've learned after 14 holiday seasons in Vancouver, Washington:

The Great Cookie Debate—sugar vs. gingerbread, homemade vs. Crumbl, frosted vs. plain—isn't actually about cookies. It's about finding joy in the small traditions that make December in the Pacific Northwest special.

It's about flour-covered counters and kids licking beaters. It's about the smell of cinnamon filling your home when it's dark and rainy outside. It's about delivering plates to neighbors and watching their faces light up. It's about carrying on recipes from grandparents and creating new traditions with your own family.

Whether you're a serious baker who spends three days making seven varieties of cookies, or you're picking up a pink Crumbl box on your way to a party, or you're buying a tray from the Fred Meyer bakery because that's what fits your life right now—you're doing it right.

The holidays in Vancouver, WA can be challenging. The darkness is real. The rain is constant. But when you bite into a warm cookie—whether it's your grandma's gingerbread recipe or a ridiculous Crumbl creation with three kinds of frosting—there's a moment of pure happiness.

And that's what the season is really about.

So bake the cookies. Buy the cookies. Share the cookies. Argue passionately about which cookie is best. And then eat way too many of all of them.

That's the Vancouver, WA way.

Happy holidays, and may your cookie plates be full and your frosting perfectly spreadable.

Considering a move to Vancouver, WA? Contact Realtor Cas to discover why Clark County's strong sense of community, local traditions, and quality of life make it one of the best places to call home in the Pacific Northwest.

Sign up for my monthly newsletter to receive expert advice, important local updates, and insider knowledge on the best ways to thrive in this unique region. Whether you're buying, selling, or simply curious about life in the Pacific Northwest, I've got you covered.

👉 Join my newsletter today and never miss a beat! Just enter your email below and get exclusive access to all things Southwest Washington. Let’s stay connected!

Related Articles:

• Surviving The Big Dark: Vancouver WA Winter Darkness Guide
• Best Coffee Shops in Vancouver WA for Cozy Season
• Pacific Northwest Food Traditions: A Seasonal Guide
• Family Activities in Vancouver, WA During Winter
• Moving to Vancouver, Washington: Community & Lifestyle Guide